This homemade, no-fail whole30 mayonnaise recipe will change your life! It is light & fluffy with a rich flavor – you will never buy store-bought again!
Whole30 Mayonnaise
I never thought I would make homemade mayonnaise when I can just buy a jar at the store. After all, it’s dairy-free and cheap. But let me tell you, after discovering just how easy it is to make my own I changed my mind.
Not even to mention how much better it tastes and the junk ingredients you can avoid when making your own. It’s perfect when making Homemade Chicken Salad and the sauce for Whole30 Fish Tacos!
Not all but most commercial mayonnaise you can buy at the store – including Olive Oil mayonnaise – have other yuck oils in them as their main ingredient. Vegetable oils such as canola, soybean, corn, and cottonseed are the oils most common in store-bought mayonnaise.
They are highly processed, contain trans fats, and/or are very high in omega-6 fatty acids which causes inflammation in the body. This can lead to numerous health problems. Another problem is that they usually have added sugar and artificial ingredients.
But I’m here to tell you that making your own is REALLY EASY and the taste is beyond compare! All you need is a food processor, a few simple ingredients, and 5 minutes – really, just 5 minutes!
While this isn’t by any means a revolutionary recipe, I’ve learned a lot in my quest to make perfect mayonnaise every time. So I want to share what I’ve learned so you don’t have any “flops” like me. Here are some things you need to know:
Tips For Perfect Homemade Mayonnaise
- All of your ingredients MUST be room temperature or it will not thicken. You can place your eggs in warm water for 5 to 10 minutes. You can also leave them at room temperature for about an hour. I set mine on the counter the night before – no need to worry, the egg won’t go bad!
- The kind of olive oil you use AND the brand you use matter! When making mayo, extra virgin olive oil it is too heavy and will leave a really bitter taste so you need to use extra light tasting olive oil. But not all extra light olive oils are the same, it took me a long time to figure out why sometimes my mayonnaise tasted awesome and other times it was bitter – some brands of extra light olive oil still have a strong taste! So I started using Filippo Berio brand every time because the taste is very neutral and it always turns out perfect. If you buy another brand, I recommend tasting it before you make the mayo. If it has any olive taste to it, your mayo will be bitter. I’ve heard of people using MCT oil also since it’s a neutral-tasting oil with good results but haven’t tried it myself.
- Buy pasteurized eggs. I didn’t make homemade mayo for a long time because I was worried about the raw egg. But then I discovered that you can buy pasteurized eggs, which are safe to eat raw! If you don’t want to spend the money on pasteurized eggs, you can pasteurize them yourself – just google it 🙂 Or you can buy good quality cage-free eggs and wash the egg shell to remove any bacteria that might contaminate the egg when broken. However, it’s not guaranteed like pasteurized eggs.
- The slower you pour, the thicker the mayonnaise. When the recipe says “slowly drizzle” take it seriously. If you dump the oil in all at once it will result in a runny mess. The recipe works best if you pour as thin a stream of oil as possible.
- Don’t use a copper or aluminum bowl. It can leave an aftertaste in your mayo.
- What if the mayo doesn’t emulsify and is runny? In all my years making homemade mayo, I’ve only had my mayo not turn out once. No matter how great a recipe is, sometimes it just doesn’t turn out. You might be in a hurry and pour too fast, mess up on the recipe, or you might do everything right and it just doesn’t work right – it happens. So I’m going to tell you exactly what I did to salvage my mayo and how you can do the same. First, don’t panic like I did that I had wasted all of my expensive ingredients and then had no mayo for dinner! Simply set the mayo aside and wash out your food processor. Then, follow the instructions again, but instead of using olive oil, use the runny failed mayo. It should thicken up nicely and salvage your mayo! *Note- I followed the instructions exactly. I didn’t leave out the salt, mustard, or lemon juice – but I’m sure you could since it’s already in the runny mayo recipe that you are using to replace the olive oil 🙂
- And finally, Homemade mayo is SO MUCH better than store-bought! Seriously, this will change your life. Homemade mayo is light, fluffy, creamy, non-gloopy, and has a richer flavor. It’s amazing.
By the way, this goes perfect in my Homemade Ranch!!!
Looking for more Whole30 recipes? Check these out!
If you’ve tried this Whole30 Mayonaisse or any other recipe on the blog please let me know in the comments below!
Craving more? FOLLOW ME on Pinterest, Instagram, Facebook, or E-Mail to see more delicious food and find out what I’ve been up to! And as a bonus, if you sign up to follow me by E-Mail you’ll receive 2 FREE recipes from my Keto Breads Cookbook!
Homemade Mayonnaise {Paleo, Whole30, Dairy Free}
Ingredients
- 1 Whole Egg room temperature (use pasteurized if worried about the raw egg)
- 1/2 tsp. Sea Salt
- 1/2 tsp. Ground Mustard
- 1 1/4 C Extra Light Tasting Olive Oil Filippo Berio brand (See above, the brand matters!)
- 1 Tbsp. Lemon Juice room temperature
Instructions
- Place the egg, salt, ground mustard and 1/4 C of the olive oil into the bowl of a food processor.
- Whirl on low until combined.
- While the processor is still running, SLOWLY drizzle the remaining olive oil in, this should take you about 3 minutes. Resist the urge to dump it in at the end.
- Add the lemon juice and pulse on low until combined.
- Place in fridge for 30 minutes to an hour.
- Store in a sealed container in the fridge. The mayonnaise will be good until one week past the egg's expiration date.
Notes
- All of your ingredients MUST be room temperature or it will not thicken. You can place your eggs in warm water for 5 to 10 minutes. You can also leave them at room temperature for about an hour. I set mine on the counter the night before - no need to worry, the egg won't go bad!
- The kind of olive oil you use AND the brand you use matter! When making mayo, extra virgin olive oil it is too heavy and will leave a really bitter taste so you need to use extra light tasting olive oil. But not all extra light olive oils are the same, it took me a long time to figure out why sometimes my mayonnaise tasted awesome and other times it was bitter - some brands of extra light olive oil still have a strong taste! So I started using Filippo Berio brand every time because the taste is very neutral and it always turns out perfect. If you buy another brand, I recommend tasting it before you make the mayo. If it has any olive taste to it, your mayo will be bitter. I've heard of people using MCT oil also since it's a neutral-tasting oil with good results but haven't tried it myself.
- Buy pasteurized eggs. I didn't make homemade mayo for a long time because I was worried about the raw egg. But then I discovered that you can buy pasteurized eggs, which are safe to eat raw! If you don't want to spend the money on pasteurized eggs, you can pasteurize them yourself - just google it! Or you can buy good quality cage-free eggs and wash the egg shell to remove any bacteria that might contaminate the egg when broken. However, it's not guaranteed like pasteurized eggs.
- The slower you pour, the thicker the mayonnaise. When the recipe says "slowly drizzle" take it seriously. If you dump the oil in all at once it will result in a runny mess. The recipe works best if you pour as thin a stream of oil as possible.
- Don't use a copper or aluminum bowl. It can leave an aftertaste in your mayo.
- What if the mayo doesn't emulsify and is runny? In all my years making homemade mayo, I've only had my mayo not turn out once. No matter how great a recipe is, sometimes it just doesn't turn out. You might be in a hurry and pour too fast, mess up on the recipe, or you might do everything right and it just doesn't work right - it happens. So I'm going to tell you exactly what I did to salvage my mayo and how you can do the same. First, don't panic like I did that I had wasted all of my expensive ingredients and then had no mayo for dinner! Simply set the mayo aside and wash out your food processor. Then, follow the instructions again, but instead of using olive oil, use the runny failed mayo. It should thicken up nicely and salvage your mayo! *Note- I followed the instructions exactly. I didn't leave out the salt, mustard, or lemon juice - but I'm sure you could since it's already in the runny mayo recipe that you are using to replace the olive oil 🙂
- And finally, Homemade mayo is SO MUCH better than store-bought! Seriously, this will change your life. Homemade mayo is light, fluffy, creamy, non-gloopy, and has a richer flavor. It's amazing.
Nutritional information is approximate and may vary.
Is 1 1/2 C of olive oil 1 and a half cups?
Yes, it is! I hope you like it!
-Cassidy
Greetings from Singapore! I have been holding off eating egg mayonnaise (which I make for the whole family) ever since I decided to cut out sugar from my diet. The store bought ones all have sugar in them. And I was so happy to find your recipe!
Tried it today and it turns out superb!! The one I made looks way more of a yellow mayo than yours but the taste is so good! I’m so having egg mayo tomorrow!! Thank you, Cassidy!
Tried it and it works!! Yummy!! I forgot to buy dry mustard so I used the Djon mustard I had with me. Takes about 1 tsp of it instead and the taste is great! Thanks Cassidy! Now I have a no-sugar mayo to eat my chicken wrap with!
I just made this mayo after 3 different recipes that had failed. I am so excited I kept looking and kept trying. This will be a keeper! Thanks for all the helpful hints in the notes especially following the 3 minute time of pouring in the olive oil and also that brand matters!
Home-cooked food is always a good choice to eat. Thank you for sharing this amazing recipe with us!
This was great! I used the food pusher to drizzle my oil in! It has 2 tiny holes in the bottom ( at least mine does!) and i drizzled the oil into it and it dripped in… it has nice flavour and was way too easy to make!! Thanks for sharing!
Made this recipe twice so far. It’s gets nice and thick (similar to store bought mayo) until I add the lemon juice. Once I add the lemon juice, the consistency gets runny and kind of separated. Any suggestions?
Hi Patrick! That’s strange, that’s never happened to me – sorry!!! Maybe try adding the lemon juice before you start blending or try adding a bit less – or both! Let me know how it goes!
-Cassidy
Bought a food processor specially to make homemade mayo on day 13 of my Whole30. Did this recipe and turned out watery no matter how slowly I drizzled the oil. 🙁 I wasn’t sure if it’s because my processor doesn’t have a low speed or if the blade was too high. Did as instructed above and reported the mixture and it came together! Not as fluffy as I was hoping but that’s probably due to not having a low speed, but so glad I didn’t have to throw everything out! Much better tasting than store bought.
Hi Kaylyn!
I actually just bought a new food processor and am having the same problem! I think it’s because the blade is too high on mine. The first time I used it to make mayo mine turned out runny too and I had to use my trick (basically doubling the recipe) to salvage it. Since then, I’ve found that as long as I double the recipe from the start it turns out fine. I hope this helps and I’m so happy you were able to salvage your mayo!!!
-Cassidy
Just finished making this mayo successfully after the first disaster. However I followed your instructions and redid it with the runny stuff, and it came out perfect. I just had a problem with the slow drizzle. So I solved this by using a teaspoon at a time. That helped a lot. No more store brought garbage and expensive “healthy” brands.
Yay, I’m so happy you were able to salvage your runny mayo and you liked it!!! For awhile I got lazy and started buying the expensive “healthy” brands, but after I started making the homemade again, it’s SO much better and really doesn’t take that long. I’m never going back, lol!
-Cassidy
Making this is easier than driving to the grocery store, picking up a jar of mayo and driving
home and it’s healthier! Has anyone tried doubling the recipe?
I’m just getting into looking at making my own stuff. however, as a soap maker, an issue that came up a few years ago and is still a problem is adulterated olive oil. i do not know if this is only for evoo, or all olive oil, but fake olive oil is real and a real problem. fillipo is on the list for bad oils. some companies will either add other oils in, or completely replace olive oil and add chlorophyl for color. you can google this and read about it. i just found a current article about it from april 2019 and lists approved oils. this was at realfoodforlife dot com. just thought i would give you a heads up. thanks for sharing your wisdom. i am looking forward to reading more of your recipes.
WOW! This mayo is amazing! I’m halfway through doing whole30 and was having a hard time finding a compliant mayonnaise that even tasted tolerable! They all had a really strong avocado oil taste! This mayonnaise was not only super easy and quick to make,I can’t get over how awesome it tastes!!! I’m never buying store bought mayo again! Thank you so much for sharing this recipe!
Excellent recipe. Suoer easy! But follow ALL directions to a T! I made 1 batch and followed everything down to the blender speed. My hubby made a second batch and turned the blender up to high and as a result the mayo turned out a bit thinner. Blender/processor speed DOES matter with this recipe!
Now that I know how easy this is to make, I’ll not be buying it from the store anymore!
I’ve never successfully made homemade mayo until this recipe. Thank you!! So yummy 🙂
Thank you Briana!!! I’m so excited it was successful 🙂
-Cassidy
What can you use in place of dry mustard? Could you use Dijon mustard or is that completely different?
Hi Heather!
Yes, I think you could use prepared mustard instead of dry mustard! I’ve tried it with yellow mustard and it turned out good but never with Dijon. Dijon might slightly alter the taste, but it should still work 🙂
-Cassidy
Can I use a vitamix
I don’t have a food processor?
Thanks!
Hi Natasha! I’ve made it work in a vitamix before, but it’s a little tricky. It’s been awhile since I tried it in a vitamix, but from what I remember I drizzled in the oil while the blender was set somewhere between 6 and 8 and it thickened way earlier than with a food processor so I didn’t use as much oil. It can be done, but like I said, it’s a little bit tricky because it thickens so much faster and I don’t remember exactly how I did it. I’ll have to try it again and tell you all the details ? Hope that helps! If you give it a try come back and let me know how it turned out!
-Cassidy
Hey Cassidy, such a great recipe you had shared. Sometimes i thought why i couldn’t be so creative like you while cooking. 🙁 Thanks for sharing this article.i didn’t make it before. The mayonnaise are looking perfect. Your tips will help me to make that correctly. Keep sharing this type of recipes.. 🙂